Andrew at WTA blog wonders if all these new converts to snowshoeing realize all the dangers inherent in winter backcountry fun, such as:
Take those pesky and fatal avalanches, for instance. Popular summer hiking trails such as McClellan Butte, Granite Mountain, or Snow Lake become deadly avalanche hotspots in winter, and should never be considered as snowshoe destinations. Nothing like a crushing avalanche to ruin a seemingly pleasant snowshoe stroll. Don’t assume an easy summer day hike will make a good snowshoe trip. Consult a guidebook to find the best low-risk snowshoe routes. And remember that there are other snow risks beside avalanches–getting stuck in a tree well (the hollow in snow at the base of a tree) is a surprisingly common cause of fatalities in winter recreation. Learn all you can about avalanche safety and equipment before you head out snowshoeing.
Skiing seems like a much more rational alternative most of the time — sliding on snow being so much more efficient than tromping through it — but it requires quite a bit more cash and skill. (Let’s see if WildeBeat Steve takes the bait and expands on this point).
You know, Tom, I’m of mixed mind on this whole topic. But I generally agree with the conclusions of this article you’ve linked to.
Snowshoes are cool tools for the right application. They’re better for deep, fluffy, powdery snow that would otherwise bog down all but the longest and fattest of skis. They’re more maneuverable in tight spaces like narrow trails or dense vegetation. But they make for a slow slog versus skis in conditions where the snow is firmer and the terrain more open. Skis do take more skills and practice, but I personally think the rewards are worth it.
As far as gear that makes it easier for people to get out there and get themselves in trouble: That’s a rant I’ve been polishing un-published for several years. On one hand, casual, non-extreme outdoors activities are far less dangerous than the “don’t try this at home” images we get in commercial media. On the other hand, our increasingly urban culture is giving fewer people respect for the power of nature. That respect would normally instill the caution to learn proper skills in the presence of the right kind of mentor before you strike out on your own; skills like navigation, snow camping, and avalanche safety.
I think the place to start with snowshoe-hiking or cross-country skiing are the groomed-trail resorts where someone will come by and sweep for you at the end of the day. And for backcountry activities, my advice is, always go with a group that matches your skill level.
So Tom, when are you going to give cross-country skiing a try?
I’m sorta resistant to the idea of having to buy even more gear, though I suppose I could rent some to try it out.